When Prosecutors Decline Felony Charges in Florida

An arrest in Florida is not the same as a criminal charge. After police make a felony arrest, the State Attorney’s Office reviews the case and decides whether to file formal charges. Sometimes prosecutors decline to file, reduce the case to a misdemeanor, or drop it entirely. Michael T. Rabideau has practiced criminal defense in Florida since 1999, and he has seen how much that early charging decision shapes everything that follows.

A Palm Beach County case from late 2023 shows how this works. A local teacher was arrested twice over a holiday weekend on charges that included aggravated assault, drug possession and written threats. Weeks later, court records showed prosecutors had declined to pursue the felony counts. In one incident, the alleged victim chose not to cooperate. In the other, the State found the evidence was not strong enough. Some misdemeanor charges from a separate incident remained pending.

How the Charging Decision Works in Florida

For a felony, the arrest report goes to an assistant state attorney, who reviews the police reports, witness statements and physical evidence. The prosecutor then decides whether to file an information, which is the formal charging document. The State can file the charges the police listed, file different or lesser charges, or file nothing at all. A decision not to file is often called a “no information” or “no file.”

If you are held in jail, timing matters. Under Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.134, if the State has not filed formal charges within 30 days of arrest, the court must order your release on your own recognizance on the 33rd day, or on the 40th day if the State shows good cause for more time.

Common Reasons Prosecutors Decline or Drop Charges

  • The alleged victim or a key witness will not cooperate or recants.
  • The evidence does not support every element of the felony charged.
  • The stop, search or arrest raises constitutional problems.
  • Video or other evidence contradicts the arrest report.
  • The facts fit a lesser offense better, such as simple assault instead of aggravated assault.

Dropped Charges Do Not Always End Everything

When felony charges are not filed, related matters can continue. Misdemeanor charges may still be pending. A court can also keep a risk protection order in place, which bars a person from having firearms, because it is a civil matter separate from the criminal case. And the arrest itself stays on your record until you take steps to seal or expunge it.

Reduced or Dropped Charges Start With Early Defense Work

Felony charges are sometimes reduced or never filed, and that usually follows early work by the defense. Michael Rabideau reviews the arrest, the evidence, and the witness statements to give the State reasons to reconsider. If you have been arrested for a felony or aggravated assault, talk to him before charges are formally filed.

Call (561) 820-4848 or schedule a free consultation. Affordable payment plans are available, with offices in West Palm Beach, Wellington, and Boca Raton.