Juan Carlos Trujillo, a 54-year-old manager at PB Catch restaurant in Palm Beach, Florida, is facing serious charges related to the alleged sexual abuse of a 16-year-old employee. The charges against Trujillo include sexual assault, child abuse, indecent lewd or lascivious touching of a minor, false imprisonment, contributing to the delinquency of a minor, and serving alcohol to a person under 21 years old.
According to the police investigation, Trujillo is accused of repeatedly sexually assaulting the 16-year-old employee over several months, dating back to January. The alleged abuse culminated in an incident on April 17, when Trujillo allegedly forced the victim to get drunk before allowing her to leave the restaurant. The victim subsequently crashed her vehicle, and when taken to the hospital, her blood alcohol content was found to be .248. It was at this point that the victim disclosed the sexual abuse and Trujillo’s attempts to have sex with her.
The victim also reported that Trujillo had sexually assaulted her on multiple occasions after they had consumed alcohol together, and that she was afraid to inform her family and friends about the abuse. Investigators claim that Trujillo had blocked the door to prevent the victim from leaving the restaurant during one of the alleged assaults in January.
In response to the allegations, PB Catch released a statement expressing shock and sadness, asserting a zero-tolerance policy for inappropriate behavior, and pledging cooperation with law enforcement during the investigation.
Possible Defense Strategies for Juan Carlos Trujillo
Given the serious nature of the charges against Juan Carlos Trujillo, his defense attorneys will need to craft a robust and multifaceted defense strategy. Here are several potential defenses they might employ:
1. Challenging the Credibility of the Accuser
The defense may attempt to question the credibility of the 16-year-old accuser. This could involve:
- Examining inconsistencies: Highlighting any discrepancies in her statements to law enforcement, medical staff, and during any previous depositions.
- Investigating her background: Looking into her past for any history of false allegations, behavioral issues, or motives that might explain why she would fabricate such accusations.
2. Lack of Physical Evidence
The defense could argue that there is insufficient physical evidence to support the allegations. This strategy might include:
- Scrutinizing forensic evidence: Questioning the validity or presence of DNA, fingerprints, or other forensic evidence linking Trujillo to the alleged crimes.
- Examining medical reports: Arguing that medical examinations did not conclusively prove sexual assault.
3. Questioning the Investigation Procedures
The defense may challenge the procedures followed by investigators, suggesting that:
- Evidence was mishandled: Pointing to potential procedural errors that could have compromised the evidence.
- Bias in the investigation: Arguing that investigators were biased or had predetermined conclusions, which might have influenced the accuser’s statements.
4. Consent and Age Misinterpretation
Although the accuser is a minor, the defense might argue that:
- Apparent consensual interaction: The interactions appeared consensual, and Trujillo did not know the accuser’s age or was misled about her age.
- Mistaken identity: Arguing that Trujillo did not engage in the alleged acts, and there might be another individual involved.
5. Coercion and External Pressure
The defense could claim that:
- Accuser was coerced: The accuser was pressured by law enforcement, family members, or peers to make false allegations.
- Influence of mental health: Her mental health issues and previous threat of self-harm could have influenced her statements or made her more susceptible to suggestion.
6. Alibi and Witness Testimony
Trujillo’s attorneys might present alibi evidence and witness testimony to:
- Establish his whereabouts: Providing proof that Trujillo was not present at the restaurant or in proximity to the accuser at the times the alleged incidents occurred.
- Support his character: Introducing statements from colleagues, friends, and other employees to vouch for his behavior and character, suggesting that he would not commit such acts.
7. Disputing Blood Alcohol Content (BAC) Report
The defense could challenge the accuracy and handling of the BAC report by arguing:
- Testing errors: Possible errors in the testing process or mishandling of samples could have resulted in an inflated BAC reading.
- Alternative explanations: Suggesting that the accuser might have consumed alcohol elsewhere or that her BAC level was not directly related to Trujillo’s actions.
8. Lack of Intent
For some charges, the defense might argue that:
- No criminal intent: Trujillo’s actions did not have the criminal intent required for the alleged crimes. They could argue that any inappropriate behavior was accidental or misunderstood.
- Misinterpretation of actions: The accuser misinterpreted Trujillo’s actions, and there was no intention of harm or exploitation.
9. Psychological Evaluation
The defense could request a psychological evaluation of the accuser to:
- Assess her mental state: Understanding her mental health condition and how it might have affected her perception and recollection of events.
- Determine susceptibility: Evaluating whether her mental state made her more susceptible to suggestion or coercion by external parties.
In Summation
The case against Juan Carlos Trujillo is complex and serious, requiring a comprehensive defense strategy that addresses multiple facets of the allegations. By questioning the accuser’s credibility, challenging the evidence and investigation procedures, and presenting alternative explanations and alibi evidence, the defense aims to create reasonable doubt about Trujillo’s guilt. The outcome will hinge on the defense’s ability to effectively present these arguments and the interpretation of the evidence by the court.
Call Today
If you or a loved one has been arrested or charged with a crime in Florida, you need strong legal representation on your side to protect your future. The stakes are high and a conviction can haunt you for life. Don’t leave your fate in the hands of an overworked public defender. Hire a former prosecutor who knows how to get charges reduced or dismissed.
At The Law Offices of Michael T. Rabideau, we provide aggressive and strategic criminal defense for clients across South Florida. As a former Assistant State Attorney, founder Michael Rabideau knows the ins and outs of the local justice system and how to build an effective defense.
With over 20 years of experience exclusively defending the accused, we have successfully represented hundreds of clients facing charges such as:
— Assault & Battery
— Child Abuse & Child Neglect
— Computer Crimes
— Domestic Violence
— Driving Violations
— Drug Crimes Lawyer
— DUI
— Expungements
__ Federal Crimes
— Firearms Offense
— Fleeing & Eluding
— Hit & Run
— Juvenile Crimes
— Manslaughter
— Marijuana Possession Lawyer
— Murder
— Probation Violations
— Resisting Arrest
At The Law Offices of Michael T. Rabideau, we conduct thorough investigations, employ expert witnesses, leverage technical defenses, negotiate with prosecutors, and handle every aspect of the pretrial and trial process. We are not afraid to take your case to trial if it is in your best interest.
Don’t Leave Your Future to Chance – Schedule a Free Consultation Today
We also understand the far-reaching consequences of criminal charges, even for first-time offenders. That is why we work tirelessly both in and out of the courtroom to protect your rights and limit the impact on your record.
A customized defense strategy can make all the difference between a guilty verdict and a dismissal. Don’t leave your future up to chance or assume you have no options. Schedule a free consultation today with The Law Offices of Michael T. Rabideau to discuss your situation confidentially with an experienced criminal defense attorney.
Affordable Payment Plans and Flexible Appointments Available
We make our services accessible by offering reasonable rates as well as personalized monthly payment plans to fit your budget. We also accommodate evening and weekend appointments at all three of our offices in West Palm Beach, Wellington and Boca Raton.
Don’t Wait to Get the Representation You Deserve
The Law Offices of Michael T. Rabideau are here for you when you need us most. Our sole focus is protecting your rights and resolving your criminal case as favorably as possible. Don’t go through this fight alone. With an aggressive defense lawyer on your side, you can avoid harsh penalties so this mistake doesn’t ruin your entire future.
